iCapital Market Pulse: It’s The Most Pivotal Time of the Year (for the Fed)

---

Arguably the most important Fed meeting of the year takes place this week. After a series of incremental steps to telegraph to the market that they will be tapering from a record level of monetary accommodation, many may perceive this particular meeting as the pivot from accommodative to restrictive, from dovish to hawkish. We think this would be a mischaracterization, and any negative market reaction will likely exaggerate the degree of tightening that is actually taking place. Here is why.

Fed finally marking to market

There are three updates investors will be watching for this week from the Fed – on the pace of tapering, the number of rate hikes in 2022, and the terminal long-run rate. However, the Fed is unlikely to say anything that the market does not already know.

They are likely to accelerate the pace of tapering from $15 billion to $30 billion a month, putting them on track to stop purchases by March.¹ We expect them to put a couple of rate hikes on the table for 2022. Whether they will raise the 2.5% long-run equilibrium rate remains uncertain, but we doubt that the current bout of inflation justifies it. In aggregate, the actions we expect during this meeting should not come as a surprise to anyone – the markets have already been calling for the Fed to finish tapering by March and have priced in two and a half rate increases in 2022¹. This week is all about the Fed finally marking its own estimates to market.

Tapering is not tightening

Nevertheless, the trepidation ahead of the Fed decision tomorrow is understandable amidst the spread of Omicron, and was reflected in Monday’s and today’s fall in stocks, led by tech shares. The 10-year yield and the yield curve are acting like the Fed will be slamming the brakes on economic growth: The 10 year UST yield of 1.44% implies a material slowdown in growth ahead, versus an economic consensus forecast of 3.7% for U.S. GDP in 2022², and the yield curve is as flat as it was to start the year, before vaccines prompted broad economic re-opening. But these metrics seem to us to exaggerate the degree of tightening expected. The Fed is not actually tightening monetary policy to slow economic activity, rather just beginning to withdraw accommodation from an economy that no longer needs it. Even rate hikes should not initially be thought of as tightening.

How so? In economics, there is a so-called natural rate for short-term interest rates (r*), which is the real rate expected to prevail when the economy is at full strength, inflation is stable, and the Fed is neither stimulating nor restricting economic growth.³ This is periodically updated and published by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. However, this exercise was suspended in November last year due to the pandemic.

Pre-pandemic r* was roughly 1% in real terms, and the federal funds rate of 2.5%, given inflation of 2%, was certainly not restraining economic growth.³ Today, the real federal funds rate is deeply negative at around -4%.¹ Assuming r* did not change much since before the pandemic, rates are well below a neutral level with plenty of headroom for the Fed to hike rates just to get back to neutral. Using market federal funds rate expectations and consensus forecasts for core CPI inflation, we estimate that even by the end of 2023 the real rate will remain below 0% and, therefore, below a neutral level.⁴ As such, labeling the Fed’s actions as “tightening” is premature. To reiterate, this is just dialing back expansionary policy that the economy no longer requires.

Equity returns to slow but remain positive

We do believe that a less accommodative stance from the Fed is likely to slow the pace of equity returns, but it should not derail them altogether. Prior experience suggests that earnings multiples do not expand but rather stay in a narrow range when quantitative easing stops, yields rise, and/or interest rate increases are on the horizon.¹ However, equity returns may still remain positive, as was the case during the 2004 to 2006 rate hiking cycle (see chart below).

This is because economic and earnings growth tend to drive the markets more than multiple expansion. Next year, growth is expected to remain robust, with global GDP forecast to grow 4.4% (down from 5.8% in 2021) and S&P 500 earnings should grow close to 10%. These estimates suggest potential 8-10% upside for the S&P 500.

For high-multiple companies, investors should not bank on continued multiple expansion but should focus on whether the companies will be able to deliver (and preferably over-deliver) on growth expectations. We believe companies in Biotech, Software and Energy should be able to do that. Broadly, we also believe that in 2022, investors will potentially need to add two types of investments into their portfolios to help deliver above-inflation returns – hyper growth and inflation/rate-shock absorbers. We will detail these further in our 2022 Outlook, to be released in early January.

The next weekly commentary will be released on January 4, 2022. In the meantime, we wish you and your family and friends all the very best this holiday season!