iCapital Market Pulse: Portfolio do’s and don’ts as the Fed hits the brakes

By moving aggressively the Fed is restoring some credibility—with inflation this high, rates are far too low and need to be raised quickly. Especially while the economy is still strong and there is a window in which it can act decisively.

Importantly, the Fed seems to have updated the markets on its reaction function—its focus is on fighting headline Consumer Price Index (CPI) inflation (rather than just focusing on the core, which is declining) because this measure seems to be driving consumer expectations. That is why it is important it acts firmly to slow inflation because higher expectations could become entrenched. If inflation (headline or not) comes in hotter than expected, expect more decisive hikes.

All of this is not a consolation for the markets per se, but it at least goes some way towards restoring the Fed’s credibility and highlights its resolve in fighting inflation.

Will rate hikes tip us into recession?

All of which begs the question, is more decisive Fed action on inflation going to tip the U.S. economy into recession?

Last week we wrote that there is a wider path to a softer landing. Certainly, the inflation data appears to present a challenge to this conclusion, and markets are under pressure as they process surging implied recession probabilities following the 75bp rate hike.²

Taking a step back, it is important to define what we mean by a recession. One definition is simply several quarters of slowing economic growth. If that is the case, then we are almost certainly experiencing a recession already, with more to come: GDP growth is forecast to be resilient at around 2.7% in the second and third quarters, but dip to 1.5% in the fourth quarter of the year.³

However, the most common definition of a recession is two quarters of negative GDP growth, typically triggered by a shock of some kind. For a full-fledged recessionary crisis to occur, something usually needs to “break” beyond just a slowdown in consumption, and what has typically triggered deep recessions are significant imbalances or excesses that need to unwind.

For example, in the mortgage debt crisis in 2008, consumers, corporates, and banks were all stretched and credit quality was questionable.⁴ That is not the case today – all are in strong financial shape.⁵

Could the crypto crash be the imbalance that triggers a correction? Parts of the crypto ecosystem are definitely breaking. Many speculative alt coins and businesses built on lending around crypto are being revealed as clearly unsustainable amid the market turmoil.

At first glance, however, it does not appear systemically significant, accounting for just a small fragment of the markets: roughly 27 million people or just 8.3% of the U.S. population hold crypto assets.⁶ In contrast, at the onset of the Global Financial Crisis, the mortgage market totaled $9.3 trillion in mortgage debt, including 63% of the U.S. population, while banks had large derivative exposure.⁷ For those that hold crypto, losses are severe but linkages to the core financial system are limited. This should mitigate the fallout for now, but we will examine this in more detail next week.

Bottom line, we do expect an economic slowdown in the second half of 2022 and in to 2023. But given the lack of imbalances and a sharp reset in valuations, there is still a chance we achieve the same outcome as in 1994: higher rates, slower growth, but no outright GDP contraction recession.

Equity multiples still not screaming buy

In this environment, where for the Fed and everyone else it is incredibly hard to predict which way the inflation data will break, it is difficult to make any decisive short-term calls for equities. One thing is clear—while inflation remains high, Fed actions will continue to depress multiples on equities and move stocks lower.

We might be around fair value for current market conditions, but if we are wrong and we are heading for a true recession, then we have yet to hit the bottom in equities. Market fair value would then be at recessionary levels (13.5x), which would imply a level of roughly 3,200 on the S&P 500, or another 15% down from today.⁸ While stocks have corrected meaningfully (pricing in 85% implied recession probabilities on the S&P 500), we are not yet at levels that scream buy.⁹ To get decisively bullish we would need to be on the other side of the growth slowdown. We are not.

Irrespective of the extent of the slowdown, investors should be preparing their portfolios with the worst-case scenario in mind.

Things to do in the face of a slowdown

Hopefully investors have already reduced exposure to unprofitable tech and narrowed down their positions to only their highest conviction stocks or indices. At current levels, we would not be meaningfully increasing equity allocations until we have seen more evidence of inflation slowing, the economic slowdown bottoming out, and importantly, the Fed shifting its hawkish tone. Until then, in this challenging market environment where little is certain, we recommend the following ideas:

1. Focus on stability and income (get paid while you wait): Consider short-term Treasuries and municipal bonds, given two-year durations trading at around 3.1%.¹⁰

2. Replace high beta exposure: Rotate out of riskier high beta stocks into lower-beta high-yield bonds and/or replace them with structures with downside protection, such as structured notes. Similarly, if adding new positions, do so with downside protection.

3. Have staying power & dry powder: Think about maintaining enough dry powder/liquidity to capitalize on opportunities when things do really get to “dirt cheap” levels. For example, we continue to like financial stocks, especially if the Fed delivers more rate hikes.

Elsewhere, for investors who can afford a little illiquidity, investing in alternatives can have advantages during a downturn.

1. Hedge funds: All fund categories have outperformed the public markets, but certain strategies have even generated positive returns, such as macro funds.¹¹

2. Private credit: While data lags, private lending is typically much less volatile than the high yield and leveraged loans space and benefits from floating rate spreads above interest rates.¹²

3. Private equity: Though it will certainly be impacted by the stock market valuation reset, private equity has historically been less volatile than public markets,¹³ and investors who allocate new cash during a downturn tend to see better returns than if they allocate at market peaks.¹⁴

Things not to do in the face of a slowdown

We would avoid consumer discretionary stocks as spending on discretionary items is squeezed. Consumers cannot really cut back on food and gasoline, so will cut elsewhere. We would also steer clear of stocks associated with housing and autos as demand is being and will be hit hard by sharply rising rates. Finally, broad semiconductor exposure is unlikely to pay off given that the overall sector is so sensitive to moves in global GDP, so we would stick with selective stock trades in this sector.